The difference between the soul and the spirit is as the difference
between the physical and spiritual.
Nearly every religion and society believes that the real man
is not the body, but an invisible immortal soul that lives on. But is this so? What exactly is man? What exactly is the soul? What exactly is spirit? And what exactly is “the spirit in man” as
mentioned in the Bible in Job 32:8? Is
this the immortal soul that lives on?
Men and animals are souls
Let’s start with spirit.
Spirit is invisible, not subject to the physical laws. God is spirit (John 2:24). Satan and his demons are spirit. The righteous angels are also spirit. Spirit is also immortal. A spirit being lives forever and cannot die.
Man is physical, formed from the dust of the ground. He was made in the shape and image of God,
but was not made as spirit—but of the dust of the ground, which God caused to
become flesh.
The soul is also physical.
Genesis 2:7 states:
“And the Lord God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed
into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul.” The Hebrew word translated soul here is
nephesh. This word is translated elsewhere within the Bible as creature;
sometimes referring to animals. Man and
animals have a similar, fleshly existence.
God told Adam and Eve that if they took of the tree of the
knowledge of good and evil they would die.
Elsewhere in the Bible it says:
“The soul that sins dies.” (Ezekiel 18:4 and 20.) If the soul can die then it is not immortal
spirit. The soul is physical. Man is a
soul. Thus the expression: “He’s a jolly
old soul.” Man has the same physical
existence as animals. Man and animals
are both souls. The same source of life
that is in animals is in man. Just as
animals die, so does man. And, the dead
know nothing (Ecclesiastes 9:5).
Difference between the spirit in man and in animals
Of, course there is something different about man that
distinguishes him from the animals. Man
has intellect. Animals have
instinct. Man can think, reason, and
philosophize. Man can appreciate art,
has the ability to make choices and decisions; is capable of forming ethical
and moral attitudes. Animals only do
what they are “programmed” to do. Though,
they can learn within certain limitations; they work on instinct. Birds build nests—certain birds build certain
kinds of nests. That is what is
programmed into them. Does one type of
bird who sees the nest of another type of bird think: “Oh, how interesting; I
think I will build my nest like that also.”?
No. Animals are unable to reason
in the sense that man reasons.
So, what causes this difference in Man and animal? Science has shown that the brains of man and
animal are very similar. Some animal
brains are bigger than man’s brain. So,
is it the brain that makes the difference?
Or is it something else?
In his book The Brain:
The Last Frontier, Richard M. Restak, M.D. points out that there is a
difference between brain and mind. “The question ‘Is the brain a sufficient
explanation for the mind?’ was anticipated by biologist, Sir Julian Huxley:
‘The brain alone is not responsible for mind, even though it is a necessary
organ for its manifestation. Indeed, an
isolated brain is a piece of biological nonsense as meaningless as an isolated
individual’.”
So, the mind is different from the brain. What is the mind
in man?
Job said: “There is a
spirit in man: and the inspiration of the Almighty gives them understanding?”
(Job 32:8). So what is this spirit in
man?
In his booklet “What Science
Can’t Discover About the Human Mind”, Herbert W. Armstrong wrote: “It is the nonphysical component in the human
brain that does not exist in the brain of animals.”
It is this “human” spirit that is the mind in man. It is the brain that thinks, however, it is
the spirit that imparts the power to think.
Animal brains, without this spirit, cannot think, except in the most
elementary manner.
The difference between spirit and soul
This spirit is not the man.
It is not another person inside the man.
It is not something that makes the man immortal enabling him to go from
being to being or from being to animals as some religions think. It is not an immortal soul that lives
forever. Ecclesiastes 12:7 states that this human spirit returns to God upon a
man's death. But, it does not have
life. This human spirit is more of a
depository—like a computer disk holding the files on a hard drive after a
computer has been destroyed—it holds the memories of the man's character—which
God uses later to implant back into the man at the resurrection.
So, from birth, God gives man this “human” spirit. The spirit gives man the mind power which is
not in animals.
This spirit is given to man to aid in God’s plan for
mankind. Unlike animals, man was made in
the shape and image of God to have a special relationship with God. He was made to ultimately be born into the
Family of God, which right now is only composed of God the Father and Jesus
Christ, but in the future will include all of mankind.
"The real value of a human life, then, lies solely
within the human spirit combined with the human brain," Herbert W.
Armstrong states in Mystery of the Ages.
He continued: "Man was created to have a relationship
with his Maker. Therefore, he was made
in his Maker's form and shape, with contact and relationship made possible by
the presence within him of the human spirit."
So, the difference between soul and spirit is as the
difference between the physical and spiritual.